MSP vs. Traditional Staffing: Which is Right for Your Healthcare Facility?

Healthcare facilities face the ongoing challenge of finding the right talent to deliver high-quality patient care, often under tight deadlines and limited budgets. Choosing the right staffing solution is a crucial decision impacting efficiency, quality of care, and operational costs. Managed Service Providers (MSP) and traditional staffing are two popular options to consider.  

Understanding Managed Service Providers (MSPs)

A Managed Service Provider (MSP) is a third-party organization that handles a healthcare facility’s staffing needs by managing a network of staffing vendors. Through an MSP, healthcare facilities have a single point of contact to oversee and streamline the hiring process, often using a Vendor Management System (VMS) to track hiring, onboarding, and performance metrics. MSPs are typically responsible for various aspects of workforce management, including recruitment, credentialing, compliance, and even payroll in some cases. 

Benefits of MSP Staffing

  • Efficiency and scalability: MSPs offer a streamlined approach to staffing by centralizing processes and reducing the administrative burden on facility management. This model is especially valuable for large healthcare facilities or those experiencing high turnover rates. 
  • Cost control: MSPs can leverage bulk purchasing from multiple vendors, often leading to cost savings. A standardized process reduces spending variances and allows facilities to accurately forecast staffing costs. 
  • Enhanced compliance: MSPs are well-versed in healthcare regulations, ensuring that candidates meet all necessary credentialing and compliance standards. This expertise is particularly advantageous in maintaining care quality and safety. 
  • Data-driven decisions: Through VMS technology, MSPs provide data insights on workforce performance, helping facilities optimize staffing levels, reduce overtime, and improve patient outcomes. 

Understanding Traditional Staffing 

In contrast, Traditional Staffing involves partnering directly with individual staffing agencies to fill specific roles. Healthcare facilities may use one or multiple agencies and maintain more control over the hiring process. This model is often preferred by smaller facilities or those looking to fill specialized roles on a case-by-case basis. 

Benefits of Traditional Staffing

  • Direct relationships with staffing agencies: Traditional staffing allows facilities to build closer relationships with individual agencies in more tailored approach to hiring. 
  • Flexibility for specialized roles: Traditional staffing can be ideal for filling unique or specialized roles that require a personalized approach. Facilities can engage niche staffing agencies with expertise in specific areas, such as behavioral health or nursing specialties. 
  • Hands-on control: Some healthcare facilities prefer hands-on control over each stage of the hiring process. With traditional staffing, management has more direct involvement in candidate selection, onboarding, and engagement, ensuring each candidate is a good fit. 

Which is Better for Your Organization?

Choosing between MSP and Traditional Staffing depends on your facility’s size, budget, and specific needs: 

  • Consider an MSP if you operate a large healthcare facility with high turnover or frequently changing staffing demands. MSPs are also ideal if you’re looking to reduce administrative burdens, achieve cost efficiency, and enhance compliance through a centralized solution. 
  • Consider traditional staffing if your facility is smaller, requires a more hands-on approach, or has specialized needs that niche agencies can better serve. Traditional staffing can offer greater flexibility and control, particularly for unique or highly specialized positions. 
     

Supplemental Health MSP and Staffing Services

MSP and traditional staffing offer unique advantages for healthcare facilities, and the right choice depends on your specific staffing needs and goals. Partnering with a staffing agency like Supplemental Health can help you navigate these options, ensuring you receive tailored support and access to top talent. Whether you choose MSP or traditional staffing, a trusted partner can make all the difference in achieving a well-rounded, compliant, and efficient workforce. Contact us to find out more. 

Banner with a blue background displaying the text: "Request Healthcare Talent Today," along with the Supplemental Health Care logo and tagline, "Connections That Fuel Miracles.

search content

subscribe to
the shc blog